Restaurant reviews written by you - since 1994!
Log In
What: (Restaurant Name or Type)
Where: (City, State or ZIP)
Wine Cellar
2.75/5 (2 reviews)

1314 Prudential Dr
Jacksonville, FL 32207
(904) 398-8989

Category: Continental, Winery

Upload your photos of Wine Cellar!

Write a Review
Invite Friends
Add Details
 
2 Reviews

REVIEW #1
Avg. Entree: $20-30
Rating:
December 10, 2003
This establishment is a longtime Jacksonville restaurant that has always exemplified quality in service and product. Many of the staff have been there 10 years, some more than 20 years. As with any food server from the burger place to the private city clubs has better days than others. Of the hundred or so times I've been there maybe 2 or 3 times it wasn't up to Wine Cellar standard. But given the fact that 80% of the time a burger place doesn't do my order right for a near robotic assembly of the product I am impressed with Wine Cellar's consistency. <br>

I read the previous review and not sure if it was from an out-of-towner or a local but it is incorrect in general. If that was the only visit then the person may want to try them again to see if they had a bad night or their quality isn't to his standards. <br>

Another confusing issue was after reading the other review I'm not convinced it was sincere or more a way to stroke one's ego. Between all the trying to be a culinary and wine afficiando to the overt name brand dropping it appears not to be a genuine review as much as a "look at me, I'm so cool" review.

<br>

Again, I suggest anyone try Wine Cellar for a really cozy, intimate evening and the previous reviewer should check again.

Was this review helpful to you?

REVIEW #2
Avg. Entree: $30-40
Rating:
March 12, 2001
Parking is inelegant, but convenient. On a busy night valet service would be desirable. The anteroom pretends toward eclectic local nostalgia and, to the dismay of some, succeeds. A moment of mystery arises and then fades as the hallway portal leads only to more of the same. One never can suspend the awareness that one is in a smallish, Jim Walter-like shell merely perched like a gas station on asphalt surrounded by much larger and more permanent structures. The food is acceptable, but somewhat overpriced. Unctious are the waitstaff, but such is preferrable to the clumsy, forced bonhomme now so common in restaurants that are indeed so common. I was served a filet of fresh poisson, expertly sauteed in unsalted, clarified butter in the meuniere style with chopped parsley and the addition of some oversized capers and ample wedges of fresh lemon. A splash of a vintage Montrachet to deglaze the pan added a piquant, nutty sauce. Fresh asparagus layered with julienned red Bell peppers, drizzled with Lorenza de Medici extra virgin olive oil and roasted under an open flame, and simple polenta alla Parmegiana provided the perfect accompaniments. Of course, I ordered from my own stock of California chardonnay that I prefer not to name. Dessert was a quarter pound Baby Ruth from the vending machine at the nearby gas station. Then home to a big Cuban cigar and a Waterford snifter full of Remy Martin as I sit in my favorite leather chair and listen to 1950's rock and roll. "One summer night, I fell in love..." Zzzzzzzzzzzzzz.

Was this review helpful to you?



Dine.com Members Also Like
1. First Street Grille ( 100%)
Jacksonville Beach, FL

2. West River Restaurant ( 100%)
Jacksonville, FL

5. J&j Cuisine & Wine ( 100%)
Jacksonville Beach, FL

6. Matthew's ( 100%)
Jacksonville, FL

7. Marx ( 100%)
Jacksonville, FL

8. Harry's Seafood Bar & Grille ( 100%)
Jacksonville Beach, FL


Members who like this Restaurant


Privacy Policy   Terms of Use   About Dine.com   Help/Contact   Affiliates   Restauranteur Login   Log In

Copyright © 1994-2010 YouMu, Inc. All rights reserved.