Carmines

4.1/5.0
27 reviews

200 West 44 St.

New York, NY

221-3800

Category: Italian

Tell others

Recent Reviews for Carmines

February 6, 2008
Brenda W.
New York , New York
279 reviews
We had to wait quite a while to be served here but it was worth it, the food was great and the atmosphere was really buzzing.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
October 12, 2007
Costa D.
New York , New York
101 reviews
We went to Carmine's for dinner after a show. The food is incredible, the prices are great. Everything is served "family style" in huge portions. Reservations are needed well in advance on weekends. We'll go back again!
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
September 15, 2007
Brian Q.
warwick , Rhode Island
16 reviews , 2 photos
HUGE PORTIONS, SLOWER than AVERAGE SERVICE, GREAT FOOD. I love this place with a group of people... its loud, fun, and soo NYC and has a very neighborhood feel. Its definitely a must go to. MAKE A RESERVATION!! its usually packed and when there is a trade show in town you ain't getting through the door. Its Southern Italian FAMILY STYLE (HUGE) eating at its best. AND GREAT NEWS... for local Rhode Island Diners. There is now a "Carmine's" at Twin River. Same portions, same atmosphere minus the new York Taffic and same great food. Hope you liked my review. Brian Quaglia
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
January 1, 2007
JMC G.
Washington , District of Columbia
552 reviews
This place is worth every penny. These guys pull out all the stops, good service! The food had an authentic taste that can only come with home made food and fresh ingredients.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
December 5, 2006
Andrew J.
New York , New York
57 reviews
Awesome food! It's all done family style... so bring a group. You need a group in fact just to make reservations. They're pretty quick. Good service. Not cheap. But the food is amazing! And there is a ton of it!
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
May 8, 2006
Anonymous
56945 reviews
Carmine's was recommended to us [girlfriends] by a city policeman. I wish I could thank him again for the wonderful experience of the atmosphere and incredible food. Yes ... we did have to wait over an hour ... but it was worth every minute of it!! We had a fun bartender[Fred]while we were waiting, that passed the time for us while having some good laughs. The waiter's bent over backwards to serve you. It was a memorable week-end indeed!
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
December 15, 2005
Hay C.
shtown , Montana
100 reviews
Very good food and huge portions. However theres usally a long wait after 6pm. Ceasar salads are outstanding.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
November 9, 2005
Barbara M.
Apopka , Florida
5 reviews
We went to Carmine's for dinner after a show. The food is incredible, the prices are great. Everything is served "family style" in huge portions. Reservations are needed well in advance on weekends. We'll go back again!
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
July 19, 2005
Mike S.
oak park , Illinois
432 reviews
This is a wonderful restaurant. The food is scrumptous and worth every penny. The staff is very polite and attentive. I would recommend this restaurant to everyone.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
May 24, 2004
Jack S.
New York , New York
28 reviews
Excellent italian food in the heart of Times square! Hearty italian fare, with family sized portions at reasonable prices. Great place to bring your family or go in groups. Not an ideal date place due to the noice levels (feel like you are in the middle of times square) and due to the enormous serving size! Don't forget to bring your tums because the heavy, garlicky food can get to you! The fried calamari is really good!
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
1 | 2 | 3  Next >