Pagliai's Pizza & Italian

I just had lunch at Pagliai's Murray, Ky restaurant and will not be back. On a previous visit I tried the buffet and was very disappointed with the thin cracker crust pizza. Was told to return and try something from the menu. On my second visit ... more

I just had lunch at Pagliai's Murray, Ky restaurant and will not be back. On a previous visit I tried the buffet and was very disappointed with the thin cracker crust pizza. Was told to return and try something from the menu. On my second visit I ordered a Rubin sandwich. It took 20 minutes. The sandwich was very skimpy, mostly bread with very little meat. No choice of side, just potato chips. Asked for UNSWEETENED tea, got refilled with sweet. Bill was over $7 + undeserved tip. Sorry, I can do much better someplace (anyplace) else. less

IT'S NOT LIKE IT ONCE WAS WHEN THEY WERE DOWNTOWN!!! Not much more really needs to be said. The food is terrible. The buffet is limited and not stocked fast enough. The pizza is good if you like eating cheese and sauce on a saltine craker. Avo ... more

IT'S NOT LIKE IT ONCE WAS WHEN THEY WERE DOWNTOWN!!! Not much more really needs to be said. The food is terrible. The buffet is limited and not stocked fast enough. The pizza is good if you like eating cheese and sauce on a saltine craker. Avoid this place like the plague. You will see alot of people here, however it is Murray and restaurants there are terrible as a whole. If you want good selection, go two doors down and eat at Mr. Gatti's. less

Our extended family used to come to Murray every summer for a vacation. About 20 years have passed and the kids have kids. This year, we decided to have a reunion and were thrilled to find that Pagliai's was still around. The pizza was as w ... more

Our extended family used to come to Murray every summer for a vacation. About 20 years have passed and the kids have kids. This year, we decided to have a reunion and were thrilled to find that Pagliai's was still around. The pizza was as wonderful as always. We're from the home of great pizza (Chicago), but we have always thought Pagliai's was special. The thin crust pizza is a favorite of ours with its extra thin and crispy crust, delicately unique blend of spices, sizzling cheese, and super fresh tasting toppings! We wish we didn't have to come so far to enjoy this--but then again, Pagliai's helps to make the trip even more of a treat. less

I attended Murray State University some years ago. Some of my best memories of the years spent at Murray include eating Pizza from this restaurant. I enjoyed watching them throw their pie up into the air but the best part was eating it. Gr ... more

I attended Murray State University some years ago. Some of my best memories of the years spent at Murray include eating Pizza from this restaurant. I enjoyed watching them throw their pie up into the air but the best part was eating it.
Great place to take a lady friend before or after the movies. Also, the kids will enjoy this place. Reasonably prices and better location now than when it was located downtown. Just down the way from the University and not too far from the stadium. Of course, in Murray, nothings very far away. less