Old Homestead Steakhouse

3.9/5.0
9 reviews

56 9th Ave

New York, NY

242-9040

Category: Steak

Tell others

Recent Reviews for Old Homestead Steakhouse
August 16, 2007
Justin Y.
Sarasota , Alaska
155 reviews
Peter Luger's be damned. New York's best steak house sits on the fringe of Chelsea and the meatpacking district. OH's extra large sirloin puts Luger's sliced steak to shame. It's flavorful and aways cooked to perfection. The servi ... more
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
December 12, 2006
Anonymous
56940 reviews
Bigger and better steaks than at Luger's! Would definitely return.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
November 29, 2006
Sandi D.
Kingston , Ontario
332 reviews
Excellent service, Excellent Food, and to die for steaks! A must try!
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
March 15, 2004
Stuart G.
Palmetto , Florida
4 reviews
Very overrated, not worth the money. This is a $25 steak that they charge $50 for, and the neighboorhood stinks and the decor is old and ugly. Service was very good thou.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
July 26, 2003
Deb M.
Albermarle , North Carolina
78 reviews
As I stated in one of my other reviews I love steaks. I was very happy to visit this place. The steak was sooooooo good. Cooked just how I liked it. Pleanty of food on your plate too. You will not leave this place hungry or disappointed.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
January 22, 2001
Denise P.
Colonia , New Jersey
40 reviews
Very good steak. The location (near the meat packing district)adds to the steak-house charm. Servings abundant, but everything is served a-la-carte, which can really boost the prices.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
July 2, 2000
Jerusha J.
Schaghticoke , New York
25 reviews
The steak is great. And the service is wonderful. They don't skimp on the food.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
April 16, 2000
Anonymous
56940 reviews
Peter Luger's be damned. New York's best steak house sits on the fringe of Chelsea and the meatpacking district. OH's extra large sirloin puts Luger's sliced steak to shame. It's flavorful and aways cooked to perfection. The service is always ex ... more
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
December 26, 1999
Mike B.
18 reviews
Excellent Steak. The Rib-eye is my favorite. Quality all the way.....
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
If you are the owner of Old Homestead Steakhouse or want to be responsible for updating the content of this listing, click here
If this place has closed, let us know in a review.
Recent Fans of Old Homestead Steakhouse More
Similar Restaurants
Restaurant Name Rating
Sushein

Jewish-Kosher, Salads, Steak

4.5/5.0
8 reviews
4.1/5.0
16 reviews
Uncle Jack's Steakhouse

Burgers, Lobster, Seafood

4.0/5.0
3 reviews
Uncle Jack's Steakhouse

Burgers, Lobster, Seafood

4.0/5.0
3 reviews
3.9/5.0
7 reviews
3.8/5.0
10 reviews
Dylan Prime

Bar, Steak

3.7/5.0
1 review
Il Punto Ristorante

Bar, Exotic, HealthFood

3.7/5.0
1 review
3.5/5.0
6 reviews
3.4/5.0
3 reviews
View on Map