Old Chicago Plzza

The best Chicago deep dish pizza around. If you want the steak of pizza's come to Old Chicago Pizza. Yes the pizza is a little on the pricey side, but it is worth it. The salads are great along with their dressings. The original location is great ... more

The best Chicago deep dish pizza around. If you want the steak of pizza's come to Old Chicago Pizza. Yes the pizza is a little on the pricey side, but it is worth it. The salads are great along with their dressings. The original location is great looking at Petaluma's historic downtown on the second floor of the Lan Mart Building. less

Best pizza anywhere -- go for the deep dish sourdough. These are seriously weighty pizzas, with lots of toppings on -- there is no way you will leave hungry. The pizzas are placed on pedastals with candles in the base to keep them warm, and the ... more

Best pizza anywhere -- go for the deep dish sourdough. These are seriously weighty pizzas, with lots of toppings on -- there is no way you will leave hungry. The pizzas are placed on pedastals with candles in the base to keep them warm, and the server will put your first slice on the plate for you. The salads are merely okay, and come on plates that are too small, but you can transfer your salad to the larger pizza plate at your place, which is just the right size. The staff will cheerfully bring you another plate for your pizza. If you're eating in, get the garlic bread, salad, and a glass of wine, and your life will be complete. This building used to be a brothel, and if you wander down the hall you can see the doors where the ladies must have entertained. It's said the ladies used to put themselves on view in the windows, to attract customers. A block away is the Petaluma River, with its authentic, not-gussied-up, not-plasticized, waterfront. Stroll onto the pedestrian bridge, at least, for a quiet romantic chat with your companion. less

Price rating is for Large Pizza... Sure, they're pricey, but they're the best in Sonoma County. Only a real Chicago pie from Gino's or Uno/Due would give this stuff a run for its money. My recommendation? Large Double Crust (sausage/pepperoni/ ... more

Price rating is for Large Pizza... Sure, they're pricey, but they're the best in Sonoma County. Only a real Chicago pie from Gino's or Uno/Due would give this stuff a run for its money. My recommendation? Large Double Crust (sausage/pepperoni/medium garlic). Too much cheese, though... less

This is my favorite Pizza restaurant. Takes a bit longer to bake than other places but many find it worth it (25-30 minutes). My favorite is the vegetarian (onion, bell pepper, olive, mushroom & garlic) with fresh tomato added as it comes out of ... more

This is my favorite Pizza restaurant. Takes a bit longer to bake than other places but many find it worth it (25-30 minutes). My favorite is the vegetarian (onion, bell pepper, olive, mushroom & garlic) with fresh tomato added as it comes out of the oven. I tried other meat topping also and they are equally good. Come with a harty appetite for these are not skimpy pizzas. This is a popular place on weekends so come early and beat the crowd. less

This is the best pizza in town, or possibly the county. Though they don't offer the exotic choices for topping you find at Pizza Gourmet, their deep dish sourdough crust can't be beat.Their fresh garlic, sausage and mushroom pizza will keep you safe ... more

This is the best pizza in town, or possibly the county. Though they don't offer the exotic choices for topping you find at Pizza Gourmet, their deep dish sourdough crust can't be beat.Their fresh garlic, sausage and mushroom pizza will keep you safe from vampires and get you a good seat on the bus for a week ;) less