Bentley's Restaurant

3.0/5.0
9 reviews

82779 Overseas Hwy

Islamorada, FL

664-9094

Category: Seafood

Tell others

Recent Reviews for Bentley's Restaurant
May 29, 2007
Jannette D.
islamorada , Florida
8 reviews
You must have the Lobster crab cake at Bentley's. I visit Bentley about 3 times per year when i have company, and I always get the Dolphin the weeds, with the Drunken Sweet potato and a ceasar salad..Yummy.. It is busy most of the time so make re ... more
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
February 27, 2007
Ed M.
Lynnfield , Massachusetts
52 reviews
The food is not bad at Bentley's, but for what you end up with, it is quite overpriced. I hate to ridicule the service since the owner/manager seems like such a nice guy, but most of the hosts, bartenders, and wait staff are incompetent. Service ... more
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
January 19, 2007
Anonymous
56943 reviews
I've visited most of the high profile restaurants in the Keys, and my experience here was the worst. The first night we went, we were not approached by the wait staff for 30 minutes. We ended up finishing our drinks (we got them at the bar whi ... more
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 1
January 19, 2007
Anonymous
56943 reviews
The seafood wasn't great.... prices were a bit high.... service was slow.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
July 7, 2006
W F.
dandridge , Tennessee
94 reviews
Without a doubt, our favorite seafood restaurant is Bentleys. The early bird special offers the freshest raw oysters and tasty ckicken wings at an excellent price. Their crabcakes are the best I've ever tasted and, being a sushi lover, their t ... more
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
May 1, 2006
B Z.
knoxville , Tennessee
250 reviews
Very busy and you might have to wait for a table, but stay, well worth the wait.Try the captains platter and taste a little of everything.This is the place to go, if you like seafood.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
March 26, 2005
Anonymous
56943 reviews
Living in Pennsylvania, we get to frequent Islamorada several times a year. Without a doubt, our favorite seafood restaurant is Bentleys. The early bird special offers the freshest raw oysters and tasty ckicken wings at an excellent price. Their c ... more
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
July 11, 2001
L J.
Islamorada , Florida
5 reviews
have eaten there numerous times over the years... quality and quantity are difficult to beat... friendly staff... good food... good atmosphere... very enjoyable experience!!
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
July 19, 2000
Lynn B.
Huntington Station , New York
19 reviews
If you like seafood, this is the place to go. Never had a bad meal or bad service here. Very busy and you might have to wait for a table, but stay, well worth the wait.Try the captains platter and taste a little of everything.
Thank you for your feedback!
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes 0 No 0
If you are the owner of Bentley's Restaurant or want to be responsible for updating the content of this listing, click here
If this place has closed, let us know in a review.
Recent Fans of Bentley's Restaurant

L J.

5 reviews

Become a fan today!
Become Fan
Similar Restaurants
Restaurant Name Rating
4.2/5.0
3 reviews
4.2/5.0
11 reviews
4.1/5.0
21 reviews
4.0/5.0
3 reviews
Baleen

Seafood

3.9/5.0
15 reviews
Crab Shack

Seafood

3.7/5.0
5 reviews
Schooner

Seafood

3.7/5.0
4 reviews
3.7/5.0
1 review
3.5/5.0
11 reviews
Fish House

Seafood

3.5/5.0
11 reviews
View on Map